Tuesday, May 1, 2007

Presentations- Melissa Kelsey

It has often been said that great minds think alike. To prove this, Melissa's presentation concerned the theme of scapegoats. Apparently the subject makes for a very entertaining/engaging read, as Melissa stated that a search on the term revealed 39,000 books on Amazon.com and over 3.4 million sites on Google. And to further show how deeply the scapegoat has permeated our society, she handed out several comics and cartoons showing several poor bumpkins getting the tar scapegoated out of them. These visual aids also included the famous painting by William Holmon Hunt.



As a final note, Dr. Sexson also mentioned the French historian Rene Girard and his writings on the scapegoat mechanism.

Presentations- Ashley Kirchoff

Ashley's presentation focused on the Homeric Hymn to Demeter and the Eleusinian Mysteries. She mentioned that there are many examples of the relationship between father and child, such as in Hamlet and King Leer, but there are few examples of mother/daughter. One author mentioned was Adrienne Rich, the author of Woman Born, which deals with motherhood, issues of marriage and fertility, and the female rite of passage. Ashley also read a poem she wrote, entitled Tiger Lily, which concerned many things including Rage against the machine, Will-o'-the-wisp, Wonderland, and New Hampshire.

One facet of Ashley's presentation I particularly enjoyed was the mention of the religious rituals in which participators covered their eyes and mouth, which reminded me of The Dream and the Underworld, where Hillman mentions that vase paintings of Hades may show him with his face averted. "All this 'negative' evidence does coalesce to form a definite image of a void, an interiority or depth that is unknown but nameable, there and felt if not seen."
This seems very much like the Eleusinian Mysteries, where the mysteries are known but still hidden.

Presentations- Mick Leslie

Mick's presentation began with the announcement that his book was the wrong book, but that serendipity saw fit to make this wrong book the right book. The book was Walkabout, by James Vance Marshall. During the presentation and discussion, the main issue discussed was the origin and contemporary equivalent to the walkabout itself. The original walkabout was an aboriginal rite of passage in which thirteen year olds were to wander the wilderness for six months, retracing the routes taken by their ancestors. This event, as well as Mick's forced pedestrianism as a result of automobile complications, reminded me of the transcendentalist notion of returning to nature.

As for the book itself, the synopsis I discovered created a very depressing scene. Two children, lost in the wilderness are assisted by an aborigine on his walkabout. I'd rather not spoil the events of the book, but it seemed very similar to the rape of persephone, where an outside force intrudes upon the simplicity and peace of a natural existence and eventually causes its downfall.

Monday, April 30, 2007

Presentations- John Nay

John's presentation also dealt with the five conflicts of Antigone. The work in which these conflicts are described is J.D. Salinger's Catcher in the Rye, a book which I regretfully admit I have not yet read. The conflicts center around the life of Holden Caulfield, who uses cynicism in an attempt to avoid the pain of growing up and entering the adult world. His anger against the phoniness and superficiality of the world represents the individual vs society, although Holden often wonders if he himself is guilty of the phoniness he so despises. His close relationship and traumatic loss of his brother signifies the living vs dead, with Allie's death also being seen as the loss of innocence for Holden. The conflict of Man vs Woman is most noticable in Holden's doomed relationship with Sally Hayes, but could also be found with his younger sister Phoebe, whose maturity and role as his personal "catcher" also provide the Old vs Young conflict. The final conflict of Man vs Gods could refer to Holden's loss of faith after Allie's death, but without reading the book I'm not sure of Holden's religious convictions before his brother's death.

Presentations- Jonathan Orsi

Jonathan's presentation dealt with the character of Perseus in the Metamorphoses of Ovid, especially how Perseus changed between the two stories. He begins as a somewhat violent youth, who has no compunctions against giving the titan a face full of Gorgon. Later however, he meets Andromeda and falls in love. This pacifies Perseus, causing him to bury the head of Medusa and adapt to a more peaceful lifestyle.

This is very much like Lysistrata, where the love between men and women is able to calm the warlike tendencies of humanity and turn their endeavors to more constructive ends. I also enjoyed Jonathan's presentation because it mentioned the power of love as calming Perseus. During the discussion of Lysistrata and several of the presentations I was a bit frustrated by the sheer amount of attention that was given to the power of women over men through their sexual prowess. While I'm sure there are countless members of both sexes who are so centered on the needs of their Id, it seems a bit insulting that men are so callously indentified by a desperate need for intercourse. This presentation's focus on love made the story of Perseus seem more complete and balanced, rather than yet another example of a woman "using what she has to get what she wants."

Presentations- Porter

Much to my shame and embarrasment, I was unable to remember the first name of this presenter. Hopefully I can be forgiven for this transgression, but I could not omit this presentation, as it revolves around one of the greatest characters in literary history: Calvin of Calvin and Hobbes. Turning from a headstrong young woman to a headstrong and even younger boy, the five conflicts of Antigone were described in Calvin's world, showing that even a comic strip can provide a deeper insight into humanity.

The five conflicts are seen many times in the series, however the most prevalent is that of Man vs Woman- The conflict between Calvin and Susie is a stereotypical conflict, the dramatized traits of men and women (Men being headstrong, arrogant and forceful, Women being earnest, serious and contemplative) being let loose to ricochet off eachother. But with a closer look, this relationship also brings in the conflict of Old vs Young. Susie, as a hard-working and focused student, possesses a mature personality, giving her an aura of age and authority that Calvin finds threatening. Given his agonistic relationships with other female authority figures (His mother, Rosalyn, Miss Wormwood), Susie represents both the mystery and threat of feminism, the rigid authority of age, and the suffocating mandates of society.

Presentations- Emily Lewis

Emily's presentation focused on her love of dance. But, as we all know, humans are never responsible for any achievement in the arts. Therefore, Emily gave just credit to the muse Terpsichore, the muse ruling over the art of dancing. In a vivid slide show, Emily showed how her life and many others were enriched by Terpsichore.